Expert Agents Near Me

Home / States / New York / Middle Island

Top real estate agents in Middle Island, NY

26 agents listed
Match me with the top 3 in Middle Island Selling? See listing agents

Middle Island, NY is one of New York's real estate markets we cover, and our directory lists 26 agents here. Whether you're buying your first home, listing yours, refinancing, or sizing up an investment, the agent you pick should know Middle Island block by block.

Every Middle Island agent here is sourced from license records, and the busiest are closing at an average sale price of $505,838. Look for someone whose typical transaction matches your range.

The fastest way to find a fit is the matching quiz — answer six quick questions and you'll see the top three Middle Island agents for your situation. Our team reviews your request, and after you confirm your email we may connect you with them.

Real estate agents in Middle Island

Featured agents pay for placement. They are listed first where they serve and labeled Featured; everyone else is listed by sales volume.How placement works

SH

Sofia Holzhauser

Unclaimed

Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
12
Avg price
$604,337
TA

Thomas Annunziato

Unclaimed

Howard Hanna Coach

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
9
Avg price
$463,089
LK

Lois Klein

Unclaimed

Coldwell Banker American Homes

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
5
Avg price
$600,000
JO

Jorge Orellana Guncay

Unclaimed

Serhant East End LLC

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
5
Avg price
$606,500
WH

Willard Hough

Unclaimed

H & G Realty New York

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
4
Avg price
$1,120,000
MH

Martin Hammer

Unclaimed

H & G Realty New York

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
4
Avg price
$555,375
RE

Richard Estrada

Unclaimed

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
4
Avg price
$393,333
LE

Lisa Estrada

Unclaimed

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
4
Avg price
$393,333
JS

Jessica Santomauro

Unclaimed

Realty Connect USA LI

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
3
Avg price
$584,833
TM

Theresa Mackhanlall

Unclaimed

Habitat Realty of New York Inc

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
2
Avg price
$749,000
DM

Dallas Moore

Unclaimed

Happy Homes Realty of L I Inc

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
2
Avg price
$647,495
PS

Patricia Scholl

Unclaimed

Aliano Real Estate

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
3
Avg price
$425,000
FO

Fanis Orellana Comiskey

Unclaimed

Coldwell Banker American Homes

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
2
Avg price
$604,750
JG

Jason Galka

Unclaimed

Signature Premier Properties

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
3
Avg price
$289,990
PG

Patricia Granelli Wetzel

Unclaimed

H & G Realty New York

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
3
Avg price
$375,000
JA

John Ammirati

Unclaimed

Coldwell Banker American Homes

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
2
Avg price
$505,000
WT

William Tart

Unclaimed

H & G Realty New York

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
2
Avg price
$490,000
TM

Thomas Maslak

Unclaimed

Pine Barrens Realty LLC

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
2
Avg price
$320,000
LK

Lilly Kaklamanis

Unclaimed

Realty Connect USA LI Inc

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
2
Avg price
$414,500
RS

Robert Serrano

Unclaimed

Happy Homes Realty of L I Inc

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
2
Avg price
$374,500
TP

Thomas Phifer

Unclaimed

Happy Homes Realty of L I Inc

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
2
Avg price
$364,250
JC

Jean Chery

Unclaimed

Here 2 Serve Realty Inc

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
1
Avg price
$715,000
DD

Dana Dandraia

Unclaimed

Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
1
Avg price
$615,000
BS

Brandon Silverman

Unclaimed

LPT Realty Tri-State LLC

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
1
Avg price
$525,000
RM

Rachanda Miano

Unclaimed

Exit Realty Island Elite

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
2
Avg price
$236,500
EP

Eman Prestyly

Unclaimed

H & G Realty New York

Middle Island, NY

Sales (12mo)
1
Avg price
$179,998

Frequently asked questions about Middle Island real estate

Quick answers about how matching works in Middle Island and how to pick the right agent.

  • The matching quiz is the fastest way — six questions about your timeline, budget, and what matters most, then you see the top three Middle Island agents based on your answers, and our team reviews your request, and after you confirm your email may connect you with them. You can also browse all Middle Island agents directly from this page.