How do I find a top real estate agent in New Castle, IN?

The matching quiz is the fastest way — six questions about your timeline, budget, and what matters most, then you see the top three New Castle agents based on your answers, and our team reviews your request, and after you confirm your email may connect you with them. You can also browse all New Castle agents directly from this page.

How many agents does our New Castle directory have?

It currently lists 65 agents in New Castle, all sourced from license records. Agents on this page have closed at an average sale price of $198,723.

Who's the most active agent in New Castle?

Krista Gibson of RE/MAX First Integrity is one of the busiest agents in our New Castle directory by recent transaction count. Use the matching quiz or browse the full list to compare.

How are New Castle agents verified?

Every New Castle agent profile is sourced directly from license records. An agent can claim their profile, and our team reviews and approves each claim; until then it's an unclaimed listing built purely from public license data.

Can I work with a New Castle agent on both buying and selling?

Yes — the quiz lets you select more than one intent (e.g., selling your current New Castle home + buying your next one). We'll match you with agents who can handle both sides of the transaction.

What does it cost to use Expert Agents Near Me in New Castle?

Free for consumers. Always. And we never sell your contact information.

Home / States / Indiana / New Castle

Top real estate agents in New Castle, IN

65 agents listed

Match me with the top 3 in New Castle Selling? See listing agents

New Castle, IN is one of Indiana's real estate markets we cover, and our directory lists 65 agents here. Whether you're buying your first home, listing yours, refinancing, or sizing up an investment, the agent you pick should know New Castle block by block.

Every New Castle agent here is sourced from license records, and the busiest are closing at an average sale price of $198,723. Look for someone whose typical transaction matches your range.

The fastest way to find a fit is the matching quiz — answer six quick questions and you'll see the top three New Castle agents for your situation. Our team reviews your request, and after you confirm your email we may connect you with them.

Real estate agents in New Castle

Featured agents pay for placement. They are listed first where they serve and labeled Featured; everyone else is listed by sales volume.How placement works

Susan Falck-Neal

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 61
Avg price: $227,719

Cara Huffman

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 49
Avg price: $253,105

Krista Gibson

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 68
Avg price: $162,390

Susan Neal

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 52
Avg price: $225,520

Jon Kindred

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 46
Avg price: $268,577

Jon Kindred

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 45
Avg price: $277,761

Cara Huffman

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 45
Avg price: $218,264

Krista Gibson

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 67
Avg price: $146,324

Mike McKown

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 35
Avg price: $221,788

Michael McKown

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 28
Avg price: $254,886

Kayla Walker

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 28
Avg price: $205,525

Kayla Walker

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 25
Avg price: $205,931

Nathaniel Bennett

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 15
Avg price: $353,938

Jason Loveless

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 18
Avg price: $279,771

Daniel Kinnaird

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 18
Avg price: $176,200

Daniel Kinnaird

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 18
Avg price: $176,200

Jason Loveless

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 14
Avg price: $233,343

Suzanne Dudley

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 19
Avg price: $172,389

Debbie Brammer

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 14
Avg price: $240,600

Susie Dudley

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 19
Avg price: $156,389

Nathaniel Bennett

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 13
Avg price: $176,625

Matthew Huffman

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 11
Avg price: $356,663

Jody Reichart

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 12
Avg price: $242,571

Debbie Brammer

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 12
Avg price: $240,600

Lindsay King

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 9
Avg price: $178,250

Melissa Guffy

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 14
Avg price: $212,413

Kimberly Burke-Alcorn

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 8
Avg price: $374,667

Kimberly Alcorn

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 8
Avg price: $374,667

Matt Huffman

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 11
Avg price: $248,300

Lindsay King

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 7
Avg price: $166,500

Jody Reichart

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 9
Avg price: $250,000

Carrissa Kidd

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 11
Avg price: $120,833

Melissa Guffy-Griffin

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 13
Avg price: $161,929

Edie Day

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 11
Avg price: $170,750

Edie Day

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 11
Avg price: $170,750

Donna Showalter

Unclaimed

Legacy Real Estate Partners Inc

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 11
Avg price: $180,250

Scott Lightfoot

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 9
Avg price: $214,450

Donna Showalter

Unclaimed

Legacy Real Estate Partners

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 10
Avg price: $177,667

Ashley Huffman

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 7
Avg price: $351,000

Louise Thompson

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 14
Avg price: $92,639

Cindy Kissick

Unclaimed

Sharing Forward Realty

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 9
Avg price: $182,720

Samuel Schlagel

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 8
Avg price: $179,180

Gressa Riggs

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 9
Avg price: $126,450

Connor Loveless

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 5
Avg price: $244,900

Ashley Huffman

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 6
Avg price: $211,500

Lisa Lovell

Unclaimed

Happy Homes Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 7
Avg price: $36,000

Beth Carr

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 5
Avg price: $199,633

Amber Simmons

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 8
Avg price: $142,700

Brady Lightfoot

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 4
Avg price: $207,246

Gabi Sorrell

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 6
Avg price: $175,000

Jennie Harvey

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 9
Avg price: $62,975

Gabi Sorrell

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 5
Avg price: $225,000

Jennie Harvey

Unclaimed

RE/MAX First Integrity

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 8
Avg price: $46,633

Nakayla Molina

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 4
Avg price: $121,633

Laci Hardy

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 4
Avg price: $22,000

Laci Hardy

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 4
Avg price: $22,000

Karen Burke

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 2
Avg price: $173,000

Samuel Schlagel

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 3
Avg price: $126,667

Karen Burke

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $265,000

Olivia Thompson

Unclaimed

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

New Castle, IN

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $235,000

Frequently asked questions about New Castle real estate

Quick answers about how matching works in New Castle and how to pick the right agent.

The matching quiz is the fastest way — six questions about your timeline, budget, and what matters most, then you see the top three New Castle agents based on your answers, and our team reviews your request, and after you confirm your email may connect you with them. You can also browse all New Castle agents directly from this page.