How do I find a top real estate agent in Payson, AZ?

The matching quiz is the fastest way — six questions about your timeline, budget, and what matters most, then you see the top three Payson agents based on your answers, and our team reviews your request, and after you confirm your email may connect you with them. You can also browse all Payson agents directly from this page.

How many agents does our Payson directory have?

It currently lists 58 agents in Payson, all sourced from license records. Agents on this page have closed at an average sale price of $531,700.

Who's the most active agent in Payson?

Tamra Ulmer of Arizona Resource Realty is one of the busiest agents in our Payson directory by recent transaction count. Use the matching quiz or browse the full list to compare.

How are Payson agents verified?

Every Payson agent profile is sourced directly from license records. An agent can claim their profile, and our team reviews and approves each claim; until then it's an unclaimed listing built purely from public license data.

Can I work with a Payson agent on both buying and selling?

Yes — the quiz lets you select more than one intent (e.g., selling your current Payson home + buying your next one). We'll match you with agents who can handle both sides of the transaction.

What does it cost to use Expert Agents Near Me in Payson?

Free for consumers. Always. And we never sell your contact information.

Home / States / Arizona / Payson

Top real estate agents in Payson, AZ

58 agents listed

Match me with the top 3 in Payson Selling? See listing agents

Payson, AZ is one of Arizona's real estate markets we cover, and our directory lists 58 agents here. Whether you're buying your first home, listing yours, refinancing, or sizing up an investment, the agent you pick should know Payson block by block.

Every Payson agent here is sourced from license records, and the busiest are closing at an average sale price of $531,700. Look for someone whose typical transaction matches your range.

The fastest way to find a fit is the matching quiz — answer six quick questions and you'll see the top three Payson agents for your situation. Our team reviews your request, and after you confirm your email we may connect you with them.

Real estate agents in Payson

Featured agents pay for placement. They are listed first where they serve and labeled Featured; everyone else is listed by sales volume.How placement works

Kimberly Anderson

Unclaimed

Realty Executives Arizona Territory

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 37
Avg price: $623,500

Tamra Ulmer

Unclaimed

Arizona Resource Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 54
Avg price: $371,190

Robert Huff

Unclaimed

ERA-Young Realty & Investment

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 22
Avg price: $594,500

Marty Carpenter

Unclaimed

ERA-Young Realty & Investment

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 42
Avg price: $402,929

Robert Gaetano

Unclaimed

HomeSmart Pros

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 31
Avg price: $498,564

Brian Inman

Unclaimed

HomeSmart Pros

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 29
Avg price: $557,601

Suzy Tubbs

Unclaimed

ERA-Young Realty & Investment

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 20
Avg price: $222,975

Rayce Mathews

Unclaimed

Integra Homes and Land

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 9
Avg price: $1,053,780

Audrey Hogue

Unclaimed

My Home Group Real Estate

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 15
Avg price: $637,917

Mark Lyons

Unclaimed

Integra Homes and Land

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 8
Avg price: $1,220,500

Lori Coleman

Unclaimed

Coldwell Banker Bishop Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 9
Avg price: $880,000

Robert Linkey

Unclaimed

Realty Executives Arizona Territory

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 13
Avg price: $607,917

Jennifer Kiley

Unclaimed

Integra Homes and Land

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 9
Avg price: $878,333

Richard Pfister

Unclaimed

DeLex Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 12
Avg price: $601,129

Michelle Saurage

Unclaimed

DeLex Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 11
Avg price: $438,400

Maureen Buchanan

Unclaimed

Realty Executives Arizona Territory

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 15
Avg price: $320,667

Anthony Calhoun

Unclaimed

Compass

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 11
Avg price: $473,907

Laura Brunson

Unclaimed

Coldwell Banker Bishop Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 8
Avg price: $609,838

David Pitz

Unclaimed

Integra Homes and Land

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 3
Avg price: $579,000

Susie McCartney-Belcher

Unclaimed

Coldwell Banker Bishop Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 12
Avg price: $364,500

Deborah Rose

Unclaimed

Realty One Group

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 9
Avg price: $531,225

Maia Crespin

Unclaimed

Coldwell Banker Bishop Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 6
Avg price: $1,159,333

Jan Weller

Unclaimed

Integra Homes and Land

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 4
Avg price: $887,000

Gary Cordell

Unclaimed

DeLex Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 9
Avg price: $429,500

Mark Alten

Unclaimed

DeLex Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 9
Avg price: $433,625

Brenda Palmer

Unclaimed

Realty Executives Arizona Territory

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 5
Avg price: $975,000

Guy Pfister

Unclaimed

DeLex Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 8
Avg price: $406,833

Robert Pearson

Unclaimed

Payson Homes & Land

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 6
Avg price: $652,437

Julie Coleman

Unclaimed

Coldwell Banker Bishop Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 7
Avg price: $485,000

Dennis Riccio

Unclaimed

West USA Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 4
Avg price: $947,500

Naomi Fogarty

Unclaimed

Coldwell Banker Bishop Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 6
Avg price: $485,500

Francene Hurt

Unclaimed

West USA Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 4
Avg price: $649,500

Cheryl West

Unclaimed

BHHS Advantage Realty - Payson

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 6
Avg price: $352,667

Andrea Christianson

Unclaimed

Coldwell Banker Bishop Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 5
Avg price: $302,500

James Jakubek

Unclaimed

BHHS Advantage Realty - Payson

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 6
Avg price: $348,750

Codie Champie-Kennedy

Unclaimed

Realty Executives Arizona Territory

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 6
Avg price: $342,500

David Barber

Unclaimed

Dave Barber Realty, Inc.

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 4
Avg price: $425,000

Stephanie Henderson

Unclaimed

Dave Barber Realty, Inc.

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 3
Avg price: $644,000

Tori Martinez

Unclaimed

BHHS Advantage Realty - Payson

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 5
Avg price: $294,000

Tamra Ulmer

Unclaimed

ARIZONA RESOURCE REALTY

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 3
Avg price: $398,333

Kyle Marshall

Unclaimed

Realty Executives Arizona Territory

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 4
Avg price: $321,250

Susan Keown

Unclaimed

Realty Executives Arizona Territory

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 2
Avg price: $571,875

E.T. Saffon

Unclaimed

HomeMax Real Estate

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 3
Avg price: $384,900

Timothy Ehrhardt

Unclaimed

BHHS Advantage Realty - Payson

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 3
Avg price: $310,000

Susan Haff

Unclaimed

BHHS Advantage Realty - Payson

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $885,000

Ronald Acosta

Unclaimed

DeLex Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $790,000

Meleah Johnson

Unclaimed

Forest Properties, Inc

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 3
Avg price: $155,000

Jessica White

Unclaimed

Integra Homes and Land

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $645,000

Glori Surman

Unclaimed

ERA-Young Realty & Investment

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $535,000

Connie Welsh

Unclaimed

Integra Homes and Land

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $532,500

Sharry Mack Davis

Unclaimed

Payson Homes & Land

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 2
Avg price: $52,000

Ross Mathews

Unclaimed

Integra Homes and Land

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $470,000

Jaelyn Hilgendorf

Unclaimed

HomeSmart Pros

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $455,000

William Carter

Unclaimed

ERA-Young Realty & Investment

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $455,000

Lauren Vlahopoulos

Unclaimed

West USA Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $308,750

Suzi Wild

Unclaimed

ERA-Young Realty & Investment

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $305,000

Barbara Holtzen

Unclaimed

West USA Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $299,999

Robyn Bossert

Unclaimed

Coldwell Banker Bishop Realty

Payson, AZ

Sales (12mo): 1
Avg price: $275,000

Frequently asked questions about Payson real estate

Quick answers about how matching works in Payson and how to pick the right agent.

The matching quiz is the fastest way — six questions about your timeline, budget, and what matters most, then you see the top three Payson agents based on your answers, and our team reviews your request, and after you confirm your email may connect you with them. You can also browse all Payson agents directly from this page.