Peter McNicholas

Peter McNicholas is a real estate agent with Homestarr Realty in Warrington. MLS records credit Peter with 24 transactions over the last 12 months, worth $8.4 million in total sales volume. Across both sides of the deal, that is an average of $351,275 per transaction.

16 of those transactions were on the listing side, representing sellers, for $5.2 million. The other 8 were on the selling side, representing buyers, for $3.2 million. Most of the work, 67 percent, is on the listing side, so Peter is more often the agent a seller hires.

The average price differs by side: $325,862 for listings and $402,100 for buyer-side sales.

By sales volume, Peter ranks 5th of the 179 agents in Warrington with recorded sales, ahead of 97 percent of them. The typical agent there closed 3 transactions worth $1 million, so Peter's volume is about 8.3 times the local median.

Statewide, Peter is 4559th by volume among 75,943 Florida agents with recorded sales.

Peter is listed with Homestarr Realty, Warrington. Other agents on the same office record, busiest first:

• Michael Bottaro61.5 transactions · 25.4M volume
• Gerald Hill42.5 transactions · 18.5M volume
• Yakov Toyberman18 transactions · 10.7M volume
• Aldo Torres37 transactions · 8.3M volume
• Diane Sarkisian8 transactions · 7.4M volume
• Shelby Reese17 transactions · 6.6M volume

These other Warrington agents also have recorded sales in the last 12 months. They are ranked by sales volume. Compare a few before you pick someone to interview.

• John Spognardi49 transactions · 27.5M volume

The numbers on this page come from public MLS and license records, last updated May 2026. Transaction counts and dollar volumes cover the last 12 months and are credited to the agent named on each record. Peter has not claimed this profile, and a listing here does not mean Peter or Homestarr Realty endorses or is affiliated with Expert Agents Near Me. We collect no reviews, so there are no ratings from us on this page.