Anthony Prettitore

Anthony Prettitore is a real estate agent with Compass Greater NY LLC in Sayville. MLS records credit Anthony with 8 transactions over the last 12 months, worth $5 million in total sales volume. Across both sides of the deal, that is an average of $630,125 per transaction.

0.5 of those transactions were on the listing side, representing sellers, for $222,500. The other 7.5 were on the selling side, representing buyers, for $4.8 million. Most of the work, 94 percent, is on the buyer side, so Anthony is more often the agent a buyer hires.

The average price differs by side: $445,000 for listings and $642,467 for buyer-side sales.

By sales volume, Anthony ranks 10th of the 49 agents in East Islip with recorded sales, ahead of 80 percent of them. The typical agent there closed 3 transactions worth $1.8 million, so Anthony's volume is about 2.8 times the local median.

Statewide, Anthony is 3081st by volume among 14,678 New York agents with recorded sales.

In ZIP code 11730, the address on Anthony's MLS record, the median sold price was $719,500 across 9 sales between June 2026 and July 2026. Anthony's average transaction of $630,125 sits close to that median.

Anthony is listed with Compass Greater NY LLC, Sayville. Other agents on the same office record, busiest first:

• Kenneth Hirsch60 transactions · 42.2M volume
• Robert Lorenzo28.5 transactions · 20.9M volume
• Kent Markgraf22.5 transactions · 15.3M volume
• Heather Keohan16 transactions · 10.3M volume
• David Sanders7 transactions · 9.8M volume
• Desiree Lofredo7 transactions · 5.5M volume

These other East Islip agents also have recorded sales in the last 12 months. They are ranked by sales volume. Compare a few before you pick someone to interview.

• Matthew Arnold41.5 transactions · 34.6M volume
• Robert Scaccia13.5 transactions · 9.9M volume
• Eileen Familia16 transactions · 9.8M volume
• Kevin Delaney12.5 transactions · 9.5M volume
• Donna Volpe13 transactions · 8.6M volume
• Trish Bergin9 transactions · 7.7M volume

The numbers on this page come from public MLS and license records, last updated May 2026. Transaction counts and dollar volumes cover the last 12 months and are credited to the agent named on each record. Anthony has not claimed this profile, and a listing here does not mean Anthony or Compass Greater NY LLC endorses or is affiliated with Expert Agents Near Me. We collect no reviews, so there are no ratings from us on this page.